by Annie V. Lam

On Nov. 16, the Recording Academy announced the first nominees for its new Best Asian Pop Music Performance category. Greater recognition for Asian music is worth celebrating. But that recognition comes at a cost: grouping distinct cultures, languages and musical traditions into one “Asian” box risks reinforcing the assumptions of sameness that Asian and Asian American communities have long challenged.
The new category recognizes pop music originating from or widely recognized within Asian markets, highlighting K-pop, J-pop and C-pop, and requires “meaningful use” of one or more Asian languages. Asia, however, is not a genre.
On Oct. 1, the Academy confirmed that the category would proceed unchanged following public criticism and BTS’s decision not to submit. CEO Harvey Mason Jr. cited enthusiastic support from its listening sessions and conversations with Asian music leaders. But what happened to the concerns about the category’s design?
As an active member of the Recording Academy, I participated in its Sept. 3 listening session, “A Conversation with Leaders in Asian Music.” More than 80 participants joined, including Academy trustees and governors. In the room, some speakers struck me as careful with their words. Many work directly or indirectly with the Academy, as artists or representing artists. Understandably, preserving that relationship matters. I shared my concerns with an open heart, and heard supporting and opposing views on the category. What we shared was a desire for greater recognition of Asian music.
Many in our community have long felt that systemic barriers made it harder for Asian and Asian American artists to receive Grammy recognition. So when an opportunity opens up, some in our community see value in it. I understand that perspective and I want greater visibility for Asian music, too.
But artists can want more recognition without agreeing that one broad “Asian” category is the right way to offer it. Did the Academy distinguish enthusiasm for greater recognition from support for this particular design? Could categories that better reflect musical differences serve artists and our communities better?
The “Asian” label carries racial meaning beyond music. For decades, Asian American leaders and organizations have advocated for recognizing our communities’ distinct experiences so our unique needs are not overlooked. This concern is now showing up in music: the Asian pop category collapses many cultures with rich music traditions into one box, making it harder to see what makes each one different.
For Asians and Asian Americans living in the U.S., being treated as outsiders has a long history. We have spent generations fighting against the stereotype that we are perpetual foreigners: that no matter how long we have lived here, even if we were born or raised here, we are still seen as outsiders or not American enough. That history matters when a major American cultural institution creates a separate “Asian” category, risking the message that our music, too, belongs outside the mainstream.
In case you missed it:
Music shapes culture, and the Academy’s influence extends beyond the industry. The concern isn’t merely how music gets organized. It’s also what message that label sends to millions of people about where Asians and Asian Americans belong.
Recording Academy CEO Harvey Mason Jr. responded that Asian pop submissions could still compete in the Grammy General Field, including Record of the Year and Song of the Year. While I agree with that principle, the question is whether that eligibility will actually lead to greater recognition across the board. Evaluating the category’s impact means tracking whether Asian artists receive nominations and awards in the broader Grammy fields or whether Asian pop gradually becomes their only path to recognition.
In August, Mason acknowledged that, despite the Academy’s inclusive intentions, some artists felt the category did not represent their music in the way they wished. He said management and the board were committed to ensuring musicians felt truly seen and heard by their actions. The Academy also said it would evaluate whether to update its category-creation process, telling Billboard, “it’s time for us to consider how we evolve our efforts.” Billboard reported that the historically confidential process might become more transparent and open.
When it announced in October that the category would proceed unchanged, the Academy emphasized support from its listening sessions but did not explain how it had addressed concerns about the design. The Academy should explain how it weighed those concerns and whether it will reconsider the design.
According to Billboard’s reporting by Dan Rys, one challenge the Academy faces when creating new categories is meeting submission requirements. The Academy should explain whether those requirements limited its options and whether changing them could allow categories that better reflect the music.
If submission requirements helped produce a single category for Asian music, then we should also consider the human impact of that decision: whose work is highlighted, whose musical traditions and cultures are overlooked, and what audiences learn about where Asians and Asian Americans belong.
The Recording Academy has an opportunity to do more than create representation within its existing rules. It can examine whether those rules are producing the kind of representation it intended.
Asian artists should not have to fit their music into one box simply because the system requires one. If the rules cannot accommodate the diversity of Asian music, then it is the rules, not the music, that need to evolve.
Annie V. Lam is a Recording Academy member and nonprofit executive creating opportunities for emerging artists in the music industry. Born to Chinese refugees who fled Vietnam, she began her career in the California State Assembly, advising Asian American legislators on policy and community representation. She holds a doctorate in organizational change and leadership; her research examined identity, organizational culture and career advancement.
